Monday, 10 January 2011

T-Mobile's fair use policy is unenforceable

UK mobile network operator T-Mobile is changing its Mobile Internet fair use policy to have a significantly reduced fair use limit of only 500Mb per month. Despite this change, T-Mobile are not going to let customers escape from their contracts prematurely – including those who signed up when the limit was clearly set at 3Gb.

However, one important new feature is that this 500Mb limit does not apply to "browsing", which they define like so:

"Browsing means looking at websites and checking email, but not watching videos, downloading files or playing games."

Help, I'm confused! What happens if I visit YouTube and play a video in my web browser? More alarmingly, I've been using email since the last millennium, but never knew I was actually browsing whenever I checked it.

Aside from the obvious ambiguities, it's pretty obvious that they have no way of enforcing this fair use limit accurately. What happens if I download an email which has a video attached, or if I tunnel all of my phone's network traffic over a VPN?

And perhaps the best example: If I browse around an HTTPS website, how will T-Mobile know that I am browsing? How can they distinguish a very large webpage from a small video? Quite simply, they cannot.

I've asked T-Mobile how they are going to count HTTPS traffic. I'll update this post when they respond, but hopefully just thinking about that question will surely make them realise the flaws in their new fair use policy?

Update: T-Mobile appear to have ignored my question. Maybe they don't know the answer.

32 comments:

  1. More confusing to me is the wording seems to be applying it to all of their mobile broadband packages, which range from 1gb to 10gb a month, how can they justify 500mb fair use on a 10gb contract? o.O or justify at all the fact people will be paying different tiers for what will now be an identical service..

    http://support.t-mobile.co.uk/help-and-support/index?page=support&cat=FAIR_USE_POLICY&tab=0&id=FA968

    ReplyDelete
  2. They are Using DPI at network level. as well as a firewall. The only way around this policy after exceeding 500MB is too use a proxy app ( Such as proxifier which will proxy everything)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Xu hướng thiết kế bao bì trong năm 2016

    Ngày nay việc thiết kế bao bì sản phẩm càng được chú trọng không những có vai trò bảo vệ sản phảm mà còn là một trong nhũng hình thức quảng bá sản phẩm tại boọ nhận diện thương hiệu tốt nhất phân biệt các sản phẩm khác. Cho nên các dịch vụ thiết kế bao bì chuyên nghiệp có vai trò quan trọng ấy giúp doanh nghiệp tạo cho mình mẫu bao bì sản phẩm hiệu quả.
    Để tìm hiểu rõ hơn những 5 xu hướng nổi bật sẽ hứa hẹn làm mưa làm gió trong năm 2016 ở chính khả năng kết nối và tương tác nổi bật trong thiết kế hãy cùng memilus theo dõi ngay bài viết dưới đây. Chắc chắn đây sẽ là những xu hướng tuyệt vời để bạn tham khảo và bắt đầu cho một năm sáng tạo đầy bất ngờ và thú vị.
    1. Tối giản trong các thương hiệu cao cấp
    Xu hướng thiết kế tối giản đang ngày càng phát triển và được ứng dụng rộng rãi trong các thiết kế có tính thương mại. Năm 2015 là năm mà sự tối giản trong thiết kế rất được ưa chuộng và lên ngôi trong mọi linh vực thiết kế từ bìa sách, web hay áp phích quảng cáo... Nhất là thông qua cuốn sách nghệ thuật đang rất được bán chạy của tác giả Marie Kondo có tên Tiếng Anh là The Life-Changing Magic of Tidying Up. Mọi người dường như thấy được sự tối giản trong nghệ thuật là rất cần thiết và làm tăng sự tinh tế hơn cho các thiết kế, sự đơn giản thường trường tồn với thời gian hơn là so với những thiết kế quá cầu kỳ bởi nó khiến mọi thứ trở nên đơn giản và sạch sẽ hơn về thẩm mỹ. Nổi bật nhất có thể kể đến thiết kế bao bì chiếc ly màu đỏ của Starbucks vô cùng tinh tế và hiện đại, hơn nữa lại không kém phần nổi bật và rất thích hợp với chủ đề - đây có thể coi là ví dụ nổi tiếng nhất của thiết kế tối giản trong năm 2015 vừa qua.
    >.>Bạn có thể tham khảo thêm một số mẫu thiết kế báo cáo thường niên chuyên nghiệp do công ty memilus thiết kế. Được nhiều khách hàng tin dùng và chọn lựa.
    Nhìn lướt qua kẹo trong cửa hàng rau quả lối đi, và bạn có thể nhìn thấy thanh Snickers dán nhãn "điên rồ" hoặc "kích thích". Các chiến quảng cáo của họ còn thú vị đến mức, trên các phương tiện trực tuyến họ cho phép mọi người chọn phiên bản của mình về cách họ phản ứng khi đang đói.
    Thiết kế bao bì tương tác có khả năng sẽ tiếp tục phát triển trong những năm tới. Một vài công ty đã tạo ra những vận động tương tác khá trục trặc và có phần sai hướng (Như một vài mục gây ra sự lúng túng trong chiến dịch tương tác cá nhân của Nutella), và việc tìm kiếm những cách thức mới để tiếp cận với cá nhân các khách hàng vẫn là điều cần phải thay đổi nhiều trong thời gian tới. Về mặt thiết kế, điều này có nghĩa là nhiều tên hay khẩu hiệu chiến dịch với các lời mời để chia sẻ trên phương tiện truyền thông xã hội sẽ ngày một quan trọng và sẽ xuất hiện ngày một nhiều hơn. Doanh nghiệp có thể tìm kiếm logo năng động hơn để khách hàng có thể lựa chọn và tạo ra sự tương tác linh hoạt nhất.
    Nếu có nhu cầu hãy liên hệ ngay với chúng tôi để được tư vấn và chọn phương án thiết kế tốt nhất. Chúng chuyên nhận thiết kế nhận diện thương hiệu cho công ty hay cá nhân với đội ngũ nhân viên tốt nhất nhiều năm kinh nghiệm trong lĩnh vực. Không những thế chúng tôi còn nhận thiết kế logo công ty chuyên nghiệp đối với công ty doanh nghiệp hay cửa hàng. Chúng tôi hy vọng được hợp tác với khách hàng và sẽ đem đến những thông tin và sản phẩm tốt nhất đến quý khách.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This is a tricky one. T-Mobile's new fair use policy of 500Mb per month must be clarified, and it's hard to see how they can accurately enforce it. There are ambiguities, and HTTPS traffic won't be counted is particularly worrying. If you're concerned about this, consider looking for a java coursework service to help you with this issue.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Accidente mortal de Motocicleta en Virginia Beach
    The review of content asserting that T-Mobile's fair use policy is unenforceable requires careful consideration of legal and policy aspects. Key elements include title clarity, introduction clarity, legal basis, policy analysis, case examples, regulatory compliance, provider comparison, consumer rights, contradictory opinions, court cases or legal actions, privacy considerations, user experience, transparency and communication, consumer awareness, and conclusion and implications. Title clarity ensures the content effectively conveys the main argument, while introduction clarifies the topic and argument. Legal basis evaluates whether the content provides a strong legal basis for the claim, with references to relevant laws and regulations. Policy analysis assesses the depth of the policy analysis, including a breakdown of the policy's terms and conditions. Case examples or precedents should be included to support the argument. Regulatory compliance discusses T-Mobile's compliance with relevant regulatory bodies and how it impacts the enforceability of their fair use policy. Provider comparison helps provide context and contrast. Consumer rights highlight how the fair use policy may affect consumer rights and potential implications for T-Mobile's customers. Contradictory opinions acknowledge and address them, while court cases or legal actions provide information on their outcomes and significance. Privacy considerations discuss the policy's impact on data usage or customer information. User experience considers how the fair use policy impacts the user experience for T-Mobile customers and aligns with consumer expectations. Transparency and communication evaluate T-Mobile's transparency and communication regarding the fair use policy. Consumer awareness discusses the level of awareness T-Mobile customers have regarding the policy and its implications. In conclusion, the review comments help ensure that the content effectively presents the argument that T-Mobile's fair use policy is unenforceable while maintaining a balanced perspective.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Transparency and communication evaluate T-Mobile's transparency and communication regarding the fair use policy. Consumer awareness discusses the level of awareness T-Mobile customers have regarding the policy and its implications motorcycle accident attorney near me. In conclusion, the review comments help ensure that the content effectively presents the argument that T-Mobile's fair use policy is unenforceable while maintaining a balanced perspective.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Bufete de Abogados de Accidentes de SemirremolquesT-Mobile has reduced its Mobile Internet fair use limit to 500MB per month, affecting customers. The policy does not allow premature contract exits, even if signed under different terms. This change is a significant concern for customers. The message could be more informative by explaining the reasons behind the policy change and including potential consequences or solutions for affected customers. A neutral tone is maintained, but more context and potential solutions would make the message more comprehensive. Overall, the message effectively conveys the change in T-Mobile's fair use policy and its implications for customers.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Traffic Lawyer Mecklenburg VA
    The article "T-Mobile's Fair Use Policy is Unenforceable" explores the legal implications of telecommunications policies, particularly in the context of fair use. The article provides a comprehensive analysis of T-Mobile's policy, questioning its enforceability and potential implications for consumers. It highlights the importance of transparency and clarity in fair use policies, urging companies to align their terms with legal standards. The article has sparked engagement among readers, with some sharing their own experiences and perspectives. The discussion prompts readers to consider the broader implications of fair use policies, fostering a critical mindset in understanding telecommunications regulations. The article's inclusion of legal perspectives and expert opinions adds credibility to the topic, offering a well-rounded exploration of the topic. Users appreciate the balanced approach, presenting both for and against the enforceability of T-Mobile's fair use policy. Overall, the article has stimulated an informative and engaging discussion, encouraging readers to contemplate the complexities of telecom policies and their legal standing.

    ReplyDelete
  10. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Amazing, Your blogs are really good and informative. I got a lots of useful information in your blogs. A neutral tone is maintained, but more context and potential solutions would make the message more comprehensive. Overall, the message effectively conveys the change in T-Mobile's fair use policy and its implications for customers contract dispute meaning. It is very great and useful to all. Keeps sharing more useful blogs....

    ReplyDelete
  12. truck accidents lawyersTruck accidents lawyers specialize in representing individuals involved in collisions with commercial trucks. These attorneys possess in-depth knowledge of trucking regulations, insurance policies, and personal injury law. They advocate for clients to secure compensation for damages such as medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering. Employing strategies like thorough investigation and negotiation with insurance companies, they ensure their clients receive fair treatment and just compensation. Truck accidents lawyers are dedicated to protecting their clients' rights and achieving favorable outcomes in their cases.

    ReplyDelete
  13. If you need any bankruptcies lawyers near you kindly contact us. bankruptcies lawyers near me

    ReplyDelete
  14. Great article! I got many information in your blog. Thanks for sharing. virginia dui mandatory minimums

    ReplyDelete
  15. Charlottesville Abogado de Muerte Injusta
    Para quienes buscan justicia en casos de muerte injusta en Charlottesville, Virginia, contar con un abogado especializado es esencial. Estos profesionales legales se dedican a representar a las familias afectadas por la pérdida injusta de un ser querido, luchando por responsabilizar a los culpables y obtener la compensación adecuada. Los abogados de muerte injusta en Charlottesville manejan cada caso con empatía y determinación, utilizando su experiencia y conocimiento para buscar justicia y proporcionar apoyo legal a quienes más lo necesitan.





    ReplyDelete
  16. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  17. divorce lawyer in hampton vaThe article provides a comprehensive analysis of T-Mobile's policy, questioning its enforceability and potential implications for consumers. It highlights the importance of transparency and clarity in fair use policies, urging companies to align their terms with legal standards. The article has sparked engagement among readers, with some sharing their own experiences and perspectives

    ReplyDelete
  18. If you're on the lookout for heavy equipment in Texas, you'll be delighted to explore the vast array of heavy equipment auctions available in the state. These auctions provide a unique platform for buyers to discover a wide range of machinery options, all in one convenient location. Whether you're in the market for construction equipment, agricultural machinery, or industrial tools, Texas auctions offer an extensive selection to cater to your specific needs.

    When you participate in heavy equipment auctions in Texas, you'll have the opportunity to browse through a diverse inventory of machinery. From powerful excavators and versatile loaders to robust bulldozers and efficient cranes, these auctions showcase a variety of equipment options to suit different industries and projects. Moreover, the auctions feature both new and used machinery, allowing you to choose the best fit for your requirements and budget.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Amazing, Your blogs are really good and informative. I got a lots of useful information in your blogs. From powerful excavators and versatile loaders to robust bulldozers and efficient cranes, these auctions showcase a variety of equipment options to suit different industries and projects. Moreover, the auctions feature both new and used machinery, allowing you to choose the best fit for your requirements and budget cost of virginia speeding ticket. It is very great and useful to all. Keeps sharing more useful blogs...

    ReplyDelete
  20. 2nd dui in virginia within 5 yearsIt highlights the importance of transparency and clarity in fair use policies, urging companies to align their terms with legal standards. The article has sparked engagement among readers, with some sharing their own experiences and perspectives. The discussion prompts readers to consider the broader implications of fair use policies, fostering a critical mindset in understanding telecommunications regulations.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Great. Keep sharing more informative blog. boston iron works

    ReplyDelete
  22. divorce lawyer in fredericksburgThe article provides a comprehensive analysis of T-Mobile's policy, questioning its enforceability and potential implications for consumers. It highlights the importance of transparency and clarity in fair use policies, urging companies to align their terms with legal standards. The article has sparked engagement among readers, with some sharing their own experiences and perspectives.The role of a divorce lawyer is to represent their client's interests throughout the divorce process and ensure that their legal rights are protected. They also provide legal advice, negotiate settlements, file the necessary paperwork, and represent their client in court if necessary.

    ReplyDelete
  23. The fair use policy of T-Mobile is unworkable and unenforced. Despite being meant to stop misuse, it is frequently unclear and subject to arbitrary application. Without consistent standards or clear explanations, users may encounter constraints that irritate them and make them unhappy with theGeneral law encompasses rules and regulations established by governments to maintain order, protect rights, and ensure justice. It includes civil, criminal, and administrative law, governing areas like contracts, property, and personal conduct. Law serves to resolve disputes, penalize unlawful actions, and provide a framework for societal functioning, ensuring fairness and security within the community.
    divorce lawyers stafford va service. Fairer and more transparent procedures are required.

    ReplyDelete
  24. In Orange Region, a DUI legal advisor offers specific lawful portrayal for people having to deal with penalties connected with driving impaired. These lawyers are capable at exploring California's mind boggling DUI regulations and techniques, giving key guard systems to limit punishments like permit suspension, fines, and potential prison time. They advocate enthusiastically for clients' freedoms all through the legitimate cycle, utilizing their mastery in neighborhood court frameworks and haggling with examiners. Orange Region DUI attorneys mean to accomplish positive results through custom fitted guard systems and proactive lawful backing.dui lawyer orange county

    ReplyDelete
  25. It appears that T-Mobile's fair use policy is more of a scare tactic than a legally binding regulation. They say they keep an eye on excessive consumption, but they rarely actually enforce it. Despite excessive data use, the majority of users report no problems, so the policy feels more like a recommendation than a strict cap. It has no actual teeth.The general law in the USA is a complex and evolving system rooted in both federal and state jurisdictions. It encompasses a wide range of legal principles, including constitutional, statutory, and case law. The system aims to balance individual rights with public order and safety. While it provides a framework for justice and legal processes, its complexity and variation across states can pose challenges. The ongoing development of laws reflects societal changes and strives to address contemporary issues, maintaining a dynamic legal landscape.
    federal appellate attorney

    ReplyDelete
  26. Great article! I got many information in your blog. Thanks for sharing. Skilled Fairfax traffic lawyer providing expert legal representation for traffic violations and driving offenses. Fairfax traffic lawyer

    ReplyDelete
  27. virginia workers compensation lawyerDespite excessive data use, the majority of users report no problems, so the policy feels more like a recommendation than a strict cap. It has no actual teeth.The general law in the USA is a complex and evolving system rooted in both federal and state jurisdictions.A lawyer can help injured employees file their claims accurately and on time. In Virginia, injured workers must report their injury to their employer within 30 days and file a claim within two years

    ReplyDelete
  28. truck accident lawyer richmond virginiaThey say they keep an eye on excessive consumption, but they rarely actually enforce it. Despite excessive data use, the majority of users report no problems, so the policy feels more like a recommendation than a strict cap. It has no actual teeth.The general law in the USA is a complex and evolving system rooted in both federal and state jurisdictionsA truck accident lawyer in Richmond, Virginia can help you pursue compensation for injuries sustained in a truck accident.

    ReplyDelete
  29. property settlement agreement virginiaA PSA is a contract that delineates the separation requirements necessary to secure a divorce in the Commonwealth of Virginia. It governs crucial aspects of the divorce process, such as the division of marital assets and debts, child custody arrangements, child support, and spousal support.A marital separation agreement, also known as a property settlement agreement, is a written contract dividing your property, spelling out your rights, and settling problems such as alimony and custodyA property settlement agreement becomes a legally binding part of the final judgment when your marriage is officially dissolved. As a legal document, the property settlement agreement will be used as a contract. Under this contract, the formerly married parties divide their property post-divorce

    ReplyDelete
  30. filing for custody in mdComplete a Complaint for Custody (CC-DR-004) to ask to the court to grant you custody. File the form in the Circuit Court where the child lives or where either parent lives. Make enough copies for the other parent and keep at least one copy for yourself. Watch a video on how to file a custody case. A person may be granted sole legal custody, sole physical custody, or both. Split Custody (of 2 or more children) - Split custody means that one parent has sole custody of some of the children, and the other parent has sole custody of the remaining children.To start an ex parte custody hearing in MD, your lawyer will file a petition with the court stating the nature of the emergency. Your lawyer will communicate that an urgent hearing is needed because your child is in immediate danger

    ReplyDelete
  31. Despite its claims to stop network abuse, T-Mobile's Fair Use Policy is difficult to enforce. Users who are looking for clarification are frustrated by arbitrary limits resulting from vague definitions of "excessive" use. Although the goal of the policy is to control network traffic, its ambiguous language renders its application arbitrary, eroding consumer confidence and reducing service openness.The general law in the USA is a complex and evolving system rooted in both federal and state jurisdictions. It encompasses a wide range of legal principles, including constitutional, statutory, and case law. The system aims to balance individual rights with public order and safety. While it provides a framework for justice and legal processes, its complexity and variation across states can pose challenges. The ongoing development of laws reflects societal changes and strives to address contemporary issues, maintaining a dynamic legal landscape.
    Reckless Driving Lawyer Prince William VA

    ReplyDelete
  32. T-Mobile’s Fair Use Policy is Unenforceable presents a critical look at the limitations and loopholes within T-Mobile's fair use policy for mobile data. It highlights concerns about how the policy attempts to regulate data usage but ultimately lacks enforceability, particularly for heavy data users on unlimited plans. The analysis raises questions about the transparency and consistency of T-Mobile's approach, suggesting that vague guidelines and unclear thresholds make it difficult for users to understand when they’re at risk of penalties or reduced speeds.
    Goochland Traffic Lawyer

    ReplyDelete